Latest Mistake of Roger Goodell -The Latest Ray Rice Misstep

The NFL’s Ray Rice Problem

Unless you live outside the United States then you have most likely heard the NFL controversy surrounding Baltimore Ravens running back Ray Rice. The NFL has made a series of mistakes handling the issue, and the latest mistake is yet to unfold. Before we get to the latest mistake let’s recap the details of the controversy.

  • In February, TMZ released a video of Ray Rice dragging his then unconscious fiancé, Janay Palmer, out of a Hotel Elevator
  • Rice and his now wife allegedly told the NFL and the Baltimore Ravens that the domestic incident was the fault of both parties, and Palmer was knocked unconscious due to her hitting her head on the wall after an open handed slap.
  • In May prosecutors agreed to Rice completing a pretrial diversion program. Basically, he would need to attend domestic violence counseling. If he completed the counseling, there would be no other legal ramifications and he would be cleared of any charges.
  • In July, Rice received a two game suspension from the NFL. The country at large saw the punishment as extremely lenient.
  • In August, due to public outcry, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell announced a harsher NFL policy on domestic violence.
  • On September 8th TMZ released surveillance footage of the incident in question from inside the elevator. The footage showed Ray Rice punching Palmer. The Baltimore Ravens terminated Rice’s contract within hours of the video being released. Later that day Goodell announced Rice’s indefinite suspension from the NFL.

Public Reaction

Many people were outraged when the league handed down the lenient 2 game suspension after the first video was released. Knowledge existed of the second tape from the onset of the incident, but keep in mind that no one outside those directly involved in Rice’s criminal investigation publicly admitted to seeing the tape.

Defenders of Ray Rice in the media assumed that the NFL saw the second tape, and it must not have made Rice look like the aggressor or the NFL would have handed down a harsher penalty. The logic made sense, as why would the NFL want to deal with the fallout for being lenient on someone who was caught on tape beating their then girlfriend.

Still due to media attention the NFL released policies on harsher punishments for domestic violence perpetrators. Goodell also admitted to getting the Ray Rice punishment wrong. If these harsher punishments were the first move made by the NFL when the news broke, their current image in regard to domestic violence would surely be in much better shape.

The NFL has made mistakes from day 1. Currently the NFL and the Raven’s Front Office maintain that they didn’t see the second tape until it was released to the public. This is counter to what many assumed.  If TMZ could gain access,  why couldn’t a powerful organization like the NFL? The situation has gotten worse for the NFL as there seems to be questions on when the NFL had access to the second tape.

On September 9th the NFL released a statement stating the second video was not made available to them because it was part of an ongoing criminal investigation.

On September 10th the Associated Press reported that a DVD copy of the second tape was sent to NFL offices by a law enforcement official in early April. The AP also reported that on April 9th, that law enforcement official received a voice mail acknowledging the DVD was received and commented “You’re right. It’s terrible.” So it seems one person inside the NFL saw the video back in April.

Roger Goodell’s Latest Mistake

Before the second tape went public it seemed like the Roger Goodell’s latest mistakes were due to incompetence.  Now it appears the NFLs story doesn’t corroborate with the report from the AP.

On the evening of September 10th, Roger Goodell appointed former FBI director Robert Mueller III to conduct an investigation on the NFL’s handling of evidence on the Rice domestic violence issue. On it’s face this seems like an honest attempt on the NFL’s part to understand the truth.

However, if you look into Robert Mueller’s past employment history you have to wonder why this was the guy chosen to conduct an impartial investigation. Here are the facts on Mueller’s most recent employer and why he’s Roger Goodell’s latest mistake.

  • On March 14th 2014 Robert Mueller III joined WilmerHale Law firm to “enhance and build on WilmerHale’s investigations and strategic counseling practices”
  • WilmerHale is the alias of the Law Firm by the name Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP
  • A man by the name of Dick Cass worked from 1972 to 2003 at the firm Wilmer Cutler and Pickering. He was a partner there since 1979
  • In 2004 Wilmer Cutler and Pickering merged with Hale and Dorr to become WilmerHale.
  • Dick Cass, the former partner of what is now WilmerHale, is the current president of the Baltimore Ravens

So the man investigating the NFL handling of evidence, involving a Baltimore Ravens player, is working for the Law firm where the President of Baltimore Ravens, Dick Cass, worked for over 30 years. Furthermore, Dick Cass didn’t just work there, he was a partner since 1979.

Latest Mistake: Foolish or Foul Play

This can’t bode well for fixing the image of the NFL on domestic violence. How will anyone ever trust the outcome of this investigation? The president of the thing being investigated used to be a partner at the firm doing the investigation.

There can be no outcome that looks good for the NFL. This is either the most obvious cover-up since Big Tobacco or the worst public relations stunt ever. Best case scenario is the NFL again failed looking into Mueller’s obvious connection to the Ravens, which will make them appear even more incompetent.

Judging by past performance this is most likely just the latest in a string of bad decisions made by the NFL, and not a grand conspiracy. Either way it’s the latest mistake for the NFL commissioner.

Sources for “Latest Mistake of Roger Goodell”

Bloomberg on Richard Cass

If this article didn't answer your specific question, head over to our Home Page! It's designed as a guide to our most important articles to help you ditch pay TV.

Right now, there are three ways to get an entire year of Disney+ through Verizon!!! Check out this Amazing Offer!

With 58 live channels and a cloud DVR for just $20 per month, Philo TV is one of the best deals you 'll find online. Try a Free Trial to Philo Now! No credit card required!

Disclosure: Grounded Reason is supported by a small commission for purchases made through some product links on this website. We do not accept compensation from companies attempting to sway our review of products.

Dennis Restauro: @GroundedReason Dennis is the editor in chief at Grounded Reason. Before writing about using technology to save you money he spent 20 years working in the tech sector as a sysadmin, an analyst, and an enterprise architect.